Writer and Artist: Riad Sattouf
The insights into Syrian life are interesting: the differences between urban and rural society in the Arab world, the status of women in a traditional family, schools, etc. The book is good but not exactly gripping. I'm curious about Riad's world but there's no strong, broader story to latch onto. I want more of a reason to care than I'm getting. There is a third volume out now that covers 1985-87. I think I'll take a pass, at least for now.
Even with a memoir, you have to be telling some kind of story.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. It's really not fair to compare every graphic novel memoir to Persepolis but it's also hard to avoid it. Her story is compelling AND the cultural perspective is enriching. It makes the difference between a must-read of the genre and a more peripheral work.
DeleteOne to put on a library list, rather than the bookshelf, perhaps. I like insights into other cultures but agree that a bigger story is the structure needed to carry multiple volumes.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. Exoticism alone is not enough. I do appreciate Sattouf's earthy feel but need more story.
Delete